Ranked by Lowest Price-to-Rent Ratio · Data updated September 2026

Best Counties for Rental Yield

Counties where home prices are lowest relative to rental income — the best markets for cash-flow positive rental properties.

Best Counties for Rental Yield

Upstate New York's Enduring Cash Flow Appeal

The dominance of Upstate New York counties like St. Lawrence, Broome, and Oswego is a clear signal for rental investors. These regions consistently offer low home prices relative to rental income, leading to strong rental yields. While some areas see slight population declines, the underlying affordability and steady demand create a favorable environment for landlord cash flow, making them perennial strongholds for price-to-rent ratios.

Apache County, AZ: A High-Yielding Frontier

Apache County, Arizona, stands out as a surprising entry, especially given its remote, rural character. Its #7 ranking for rental yield is driven by exceptionally low home prices, with the most affordable housing in the entire list. This creates a high price-to-rent ratio, offering landlords significant cash flow potential despite the county's modest economic growth and population trends.

Cameron County, TX: Yield Amidst Growth

Cameron County, Texas, presents an interesting tension: strong GDP growth but a lower BTI score. For rental investors, this means the county offers attractive rental yields due to relatively low home prices compared to rent, even as the broader economy expands. The challenge lies in balancing the immediate cash flow benefits with the county's affordability, which is on the lower side for this list, influencing long-term price-to-rent stability.

# County BTI Score P/R Ratio Home Value 1yr Forecast HV Ratio
01 Indiana County PA 96 7x $152,800 +7.3% 3.9x
02 Robeson County NC 100 7x $94,500 +3.7% 2.8x
03 Cameron County TX 2 8x $136,500 +2.8% 4.3x
04 Walker County AL 22 8x $135,900 -1.0% 4.5x
05 McKinley County NM 7 8x $78,700 +2.4% 2.5x
06 Otsego County NY 79 8x $179,100 +5.1% 3.9x
07 Broome County NY 90 8x $154,900 +6.8% 3.2x
08 St. Lawrence County NY 99 8x $121,900 +7.8% 2.5x
09 Orangeburg County SC 94 8x $115,800 +3.4% 3.1x
10 Apache County AZ 85 8x $63,700 +2.2% 1.8x
11 Taylor County TX 98 8x $198,600 +7.5% 3.8x
12 Lenoir County NC 98 8x $120,500 +4.3% 2.3x
13 Lauderdale County MS 20 9x $133,300 +2.3% 2.5x
14 Otero County NM 85 9x $162,700 +3.1% 3.8x
15 Steuben County NY 84 9x $137,900 +3.5% 2.7x
16 Oswego County NY 98 9x $151,700 +7.1% 2.5x
17 Vermilion County IL 24 9x $97,200 +3.4% 2.2x
18 Erie County OH 93 9x $199,700 +5.9% 3.6x
19 Sumter County SC 85 9x $165,300 +3.5% 3.6x
20 Florence County SC 61 9x $177,900 +4.7% 3.1x
21 Hardin County TX 6 9x $205,700 +2.0% 8.2x
22 Liberty County TX 7 10x $181,700 -1.6% 7.3x
23 Huron County OH 97 10x $166,000 +5.9% 4.3x
24 Valencia County NM 60 10x $223,000 +4.5% 9.5x
25 Liberty County GA 31 10x $201,500 +2.5% 3.3x
26 Navajo County AZ 19 10x $201,500 +2.2% 7.0x
27 Wichita County TX 85 10x $153,700 +4.6% 3.3x
28 Lowndes County MS 74 10x $164,100 +4.5% 3.0x
29 Wayne County NC 90 10x $178,700 -0.6% 4.1x
30 Putnam County FL 0 10x $160,300 -0.8% 4.5x
31 Chautauqua County NY 92 10x $127,900 +6.5% 3.3x
32 El Paso County TX 38 10x $180,400 +3.1% 3.7x
33 Kanawha County WV 22 10x $147,300 +4.2% 2.3x
34 Onondaga County NY 56 10x $200,200 +6.0% 2.8x
35 Macon County IL 21 10x $127,300 +3.2% 1.8x
36 Russell County AL 55 10x $165,700 +4.4% 5.5x
37 Grant County IN 86 10x $122,300 +5.8% 3.2x
38 Autauga County AL 55 10x $207,200 +5.2% 7.1x
39 Chemung County NY 98 10x $141,100 +5.4% 3.1x
40 Kershaw County SC 73 10x $217,100 +5.4% 5.6x
41 Chaves County NM 47 10x $156,400 +2.6% 4.5x
42 Ontario County NY 43 10x $222,900 +4.7% 3.6x
43 Highlands County FL 12 10x $187,900 +0.1% 6.7x
44 Angelina County TX 3 10x $163,500 +0.2% 4.0x
45 Wilson County NC 91 10x $186,000 +1.9% 3.7x
46 Lea County NM 71 10x $184,000 +4.8% 1.2x
47 Hinds County MS 60 10x $159,900 +0.5% 2.9x
48 Jefferson County NY 76 10x $188,200 +5.5% 3.4x
49 Eddy County NM 39 10x $212,600 +2.3% 1.3x
50 Hidalgo County TX 36 10x $140,900 +1.9% 5.2x
50
Counties ranked
Cite this ranking

BoomTownIndex, “Best Counties for Rental Yield.” Data: September 2026. https://boomtownindex.com/rankings/best-rental-yield/

Free to reference with a link. See methodology →