Counties where home prices are lowest relative to rental income — the best markets for cash-flow positive rental properties.
The dominance of Upstate New York counties like St. Lawrence, Broome, and Oswego is a clear signal for rental investors. These regions consistently offer low home prices relative to rental income, leading to strong rental yields. While some areas see slight population declines, the underlying affordability and steady demand create a favorable environment for landlord cash flow, making them perennial strongholds for price-to-rent ratios.
Apache County, Arizona, stands out as a surprising entry, especially given its remote, rural character. Its #7 ranking for rental yield is driven by exceptionally low home prices, with the most affordable housing in the entire list. This creates a high price-to-rent ratio, offering landlords significant cash flow potential despite the county's modest economic growth and population trends.
Cameron County, Texas, presents an interesting tension: strong GDP growth but a lower BTI score. For rental investors, this means the county offers attractive rental yields due to relatively low home prices compared to rent, even as the broader economy expands. The challenge lies in balancing the immediate cash flow benefits with the county's affordability, which is on the lower side for this list, influencing long-term price-to-rent stability.
BoomTownIndex, “Best Counties for Rental Yield.” Data: September 2026. https://boomtownindex.com/rankings/best-rental-yield/