76 / 100

Cattaraugus County, NY

Olean

RANK #238 / 1001 NAT  ·  #13 / 45 NY  ·  POP 76,145

1YR FORECAST: +4.9%

5YR OUTLOOK: +3%

#6 Most Affordable
Our model projects above-average housing market growth for Cattaraugus County at +4.9% over the next year.

[01] Why Cattaraugus County?

Allegany State Park, the largest state park in New York, anchors Cattaraugus County, offering 65,000 acres of forests, lakes, and trails for year-round recreation. Located in Western New York, bordering Pennsylvania, the county is known as the "Enchanted Mountains" due to its rugged, un-glaciated landscape of rolling hills and valleys. Major roadways like Interstate 86 and U.S. Route 219 provide access, and while public transportation exists within Olean and to Ellicottville, many residents rely on driving. The community feel is generally described as small and personable.

Life in Cattaraugus County offers a lower cost of living compared to many parts of New York. Public schools in the county are rated above average, with several districts serving the area. The economy is seeing efforts to foster entrepreneurship and attract private sector investment. Recent economic development strategies focus on aligning existing resources across entrepreneurship, workforce, and traditional economic development functions, supported by regional investments. The county also benefits from ongoing investment in energy sectors, including natural gas extraction.

MARKET PROFILE

Idiosyncratic Markets

Cattaraugus County's data profile doesn't fit any single market profile cleanly — its housing, labor, and demographic signals pull in different directions (home prices +4.6% YoY, population -0.1%, wages +3.2%). About 414 U.S. counties show this kind of mixed-signal pattern.

See all 414 Idiosyncratic Markets counties →

[02] Market Snapshot

Housing Ratio
2.9x

Undervalued relative to economy

GDP Growth
+2.4%

Below national median

Home Prices
+4.6%

Outpacing national median

Climate & Terrain
-0.3

Below-average climate & terrain

Price/Rent
12x

Below national median (15x)

Housing looks undervalued at 2.9x — home prices are low relative to local economic output. The typical U.S. county is 4–6x.

[03] Top Employers

  1. 1
    Cattaraugus County Government Government
  2. 2
    Seneca Nation of Indians Other
  3. 3
    Olean General Hospital Healthcare
  4. 4
    Seneca Allegany Casino & Hotel Hospitality
  5. 5
    Dresser-Rand - Turbo Products Division Manufacturing
  6. 6
    Cutco Cutlery (Alcas Corporation) Manufacturing
  7. 7
    Cattaraugus-Allegany BOCES Education
  8. 8
    St. Bonaventure University Education
  9. 9
    Pioneer Central School District Education

Estimated local headcount ranges. Larger employers shown as floor + "+"; smaller employers show exact counts where reported.

[04] Home Value Growth vs National

Cattaraugus County U.S. National

Bars show trailing 12-month growth. The dashed Forecast bars are the model's next-12-month projection; the whisker marks the ±1% range (cooling–accelerating).

The Numbers

DEMOGRAPHICS
Population
76,145
-0.08% YoY
Median Household Income
$59,540
Median Home Value
$113,100
+4.58% 12mo
Median Rent
$770
Average Annual Pay
$55,757
+3.2% YoY
Employment
28,122
+1.6% YoY
Income-to-Home-Value
0.5264
More affordable than average
Migration Inflow
2.05%
of pop. from another state
Bachelor's Degree+
21.1%
of residents (national avg: 33%)

Market Activity

REAL ESTATE
Median Sale Price
$170,000
Days on Market
27
Active market
Months of Supply
4.8
Balanced market
Sale-to-List Ratio
97.9%
Negotiation room for buyers
Sold Above List
37.2%
Listings w/ Price Drops
21.2%
Building Permits (2025)
150
Single-Family Permits
124

Source: Redfin · Census BPS — Browse sales on Redfin →

[05] Crime & Safety

B
SAFETY
GRADE
Firearm Fatalities
8.9
per 100K · nat avg 13.4
Injury Deaths
75.2
per 100K · nat avg 83.6
vs National Average
—
based on homicide rate

Source: Homicide rates from CDC/NCHS vital-statistics mortality data — a multi-year average that stabilizes counts in smaller counties — compiled in the County Health Rankings 2025 release. Rates per 100,000 population; U.S. average ≈ 6.5. Grade reflects homicide rate relative to the national average. Learn more →

See where Cattaraugus County stands nationally: safest large counties in America · highest homicide-rate counties.

[06] Capital Investment

$714M
TOTAL
PROJECT AMOUNT STATUS
Alle-Catt Wind Energy Center
Invenergy LLC
$619M Under Construction
Hemlock Hollow Wind Project
Liberty Renewables
$95M Proposed

Source: public records, news, corporate announcements. Amounts are estimates where noted.

[07] Score Breakdown

GDP Growth +2.4% 44 percentile
Population Growth -0.1% 18 percentile
Income Growth +4.1% 20 percentile
Vacancy Rate 1.1% 40 percentile
Home Price Change +4.6% 83 percentile
Price/Rent 12x 84 percentile

Bars show percentile rank among all 1001 counties.

[08] Frequently Asked Questions

Is Cattaraugus County, NY a good place to move to?

With a Boom Town Index score of 76/100, Cattaraugus County sits in the upper half of all 1001 ranked counties. Employment is expanding at +1.6%, and median household income stands at $59,540 — indicators that suggest solid fundamentals even if it's not among the fastest-growing counties in NY.

Is Cattaraugus County affordable?

By national standards, Cattaraugus County is quite affordable. Homes here have a median value of $113,100, and the income-to-home-value ratio of 0.53 is well above the U.S. average — especially with median rent at just $770/month. Residents can generally buy a home without being cost-burdened.

Is Cattaraugus County growing or shrinking?

Employers in Cattaraugus County are hiring — job growth of +1.6% — but the population is close to flat (-0.1% YoY). Home values moved +4.6% over the past year. Labor demand is outpacing local population growth, which tends to tighten wages and housing.

Are people moving to Cattaraugus County?

There's a moderate stream of newcomers. About 2.05% of residents moved from another state, which is above average and suggests Cattaraugus County has appeal as a relocation destination — though it's not among the highest-inflow counties nationally.

[09] Similar Counties by Size & Score

Jefferson County, NY 76 Suffolk County, NY 76 Sullivan County, NY 77 Herkimer County, NY 75 Otsego County, NY 79 Oneida County, NY 73 Van Buren County, MI 76 Fauquier County, VA 76