79 / 100

Otsego County, NY

Oneonta

RANK #211 / 1001 NAT  ·  #11 / 45 NY  ·  POP 60,108

1YR FORECAST: +5.1%

5YR OUTLOOK: +3%

#6 Best Rental Yield
Our model projects above-average housing market growth for Otsego County at +5.1% over the next year.

[01] Why Otsego County?

Otsego County, New York, is often recognized for Cooperstown, a village known as the unofficial birthplace of baseball and home to the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. Located in central New York, west of Albany, the county offers a blend of rural landscapes and cultural attractions. Commuting options include Interstate 88 and various state routes, with bus services connecting communities like Oneonta and Cooperstown. The region's natural beauty, including Otsego Lake, provides opportunities for hiking, biking, paddling, and winter sports.

Life in Otsego County balances small-town community with access to educational and healthcare institutions. Residents often own their homes, and the area is home to both young professionals and retirees. The economy is supported by healthcare, with Bassett Medical Center being a major employer, and educational services, anchored by SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick College. Recent economic developments include investments in tourism, agribusiness, and infrastructure, with a focus on improving local facilities and supporting manufacturing.

MARKET PROFILE

Affordable Slow Markets

Otsego County is one of 75 U.S. counties in this market profile — stronger than typical on the BoomTown Index. Within this cohort, its recent home-price change of +5.5% runs above the profile's typical +0.8%.

See all 75 Affordable Slow Markets counties →

[02] Market Snapshot

Housing Ratio
3.9x

Undervalued relative to economy

GDP Growth
+3.4%

Above national median

Home Prices
+5.5%

Outpacing national median

Climate & Terrain
-0.8

Below-average climate & terrain

Price/Rent
8x

Strong rental yield

Housing looks undervalued at 3.9x — home prices are low relative to local economic output. The typical U.S. county is 4–6x.

[03] Top Employers

  1. 1
    Bassett Healthcare Network Healthcare
    2,500+
  2. 2
    SUNY Oneonta Education
    1,000+
  3. 3
    Hartwick College Education
    250+
  4. 4
    NYCM Insurance Finance
  5. 5
    A.O. Fox Memorial Hospital Healthcare
  6. 6
    Otsego County Government Government
  7. 7
    The Arc Otsego Other
  8. 8
    Opportunities for Otsego Other
  9. 9
    Price Chopper/Market 32 Retail
  10. 10
    Walmart Retail

Estimated local headcount ranges. Larger employers shown as floor + "+"; smaller employers show exact counts where reported.

[04] Home Value Growth vs National

Otsego County U.S. National

Bars show trailing 12-month growth. The dashed Forecast bars are the model's next-12-month projection; the whisker marks the ±1% range (cooling–accelerating).

The Numbers

DEMOGRAPHICS
Population
60,108
-0.07% YoY
Median Household Income
$68,885
Median Home Value
$179,100
+5.5% 12mo
Median Rent
$987
Average Annual Pay
$61,539
+2.0% YoY
Employment
22,645
+2.0% YoY
Income-to-Home-Value
0.3846
More affordable than average
Migration Inflow
5.15%
of pop. from another state
Bachelor's Degree+
34.4%
of residents (national avg: 33%)

Market Activity

REAL ESTATE
Median Sale Price
$253,500
Days on Market
77
Slower market
Months of Supply
5.7
Buyer's market
Sale-to-List Ratio
97.5%
Negotiation room for buyers
Sold Above List
23.3%
Listings w/ Price Drops
18.0%
Building Permits (2025)
125
Single-Family Permits
125

Source: Redfin · Census BPS — Browse sales on Redfin →

[05] Crime & Safety

B+
SAFETY
GRADE
Homicide Rate
2.6
per 100K · nat avg 6.5
Firearm Fatalities
7.8
per 100K · nat avg 13.4
Injury Deaths
70.1
per 100K · nat avg 83.6
vs National Average
Well below national avg
based on homicide rate
10-Year Trend
Stable since 2021
homicide rate, 2021 → 2025

Source: Homicide rates from CDC/NCHS vital-statistics mortality data — a multi-year average that stabilizes counts in smaller counties — compiled in the County Health Rankings 2025 release. Rates per 100,000 population; U.S. average ≈ 6.5. Grade reflects homicide rate relative to the national average. Learn more →

See where Otsego County stands nationally: safest large counties in America · highest homicide-rate counties.

[06] Capital Investment

$200M
TOTAL
PROJECT AMOUNT STATUS
45th Parallel Solar Project
RWE Renewables
$200M Planned

Source: public records, news, corporate announcements. Amounts are estimates where noted.

[07] Score Breakdown

GDP Growth +3.4% 64 percentile
Population Growth -0.1% 19 percentile
Income Growth +5.0% 55 percentile
Vacancy Rate 1.0% 47 percentile
Home Price Change +5.5% 90 percentile
Rent Growth +4.6% 74 percentile
Price/Rent 8x 100 percentile

Bars show percentile rank among all 1001 counties.

[08] Frequently Asked Questions

Is Otsego County, NY a good place to move to?

With a Boom Town Index score of 79/100, Otsego County sits in the upper half of all 1001 ranked counties. Employment is expanding at +2.0%, and median household income stands at $68,885 — indicators that suggest solid fundamentals even if it's not among the fastest-growing counties in NY.

Is Otsego County affordable?

By national standards, Otsego County is quite affordable. Homes here have a median value of $179,100, and the income-to-home-value ratio of 0.38 is well above the U.S. average — especially with median rent at just $987/month. Residents can generally buy a home without being cost-burdened.

Is Otsego County growing or shrinking?

Employers in Otsego County are hiring — job growth of +2.0% — but the population is close to flat (-0.1% YoY). Home values moved +5.5% over the past year. Labor demand is outpacing local population growth, which tends to tighten wages and housing.

Are people moving to Otsego County?

In significant numbers — 5.15% of Otsego County's current population relocated from another state, well above the national norm. That level of in-migration usually signals a county where jobs, affordability, or quality of life are pulling people in from elsewhere.

How is the housing market in Otsego County?

Home values climbed +5.5% year-over-year, which is a solid pace of appreciation. The median home in Otsego County is now valued at $179,100. That kind of growth typically reflects sustained demand rather than speculative frenzy.

[09] Similar Counties by Size & Score

Sullivan County, NY 77 Cattaraugus County, NY 76 Jefferson County, NY 76 Suffolk County, NY 76 Herkimer County, NY 75 Steuben County, NY 84 Pickaway County, OH 79 Somerset County, PA 79